Follow us on social

Re-elected, Macron faces divisions at home and especially in Europe

Re-elected, Macron faces divisions at home and especially in Europe

The French president has been pushing diplomacy with Russia and for regional autonomy. Not all of his neighbors think that way.

Analysis | Europe

In a speech to the European Parliament in Strasbourg in January, French President Emmanuel Macron declared he believed the time had come for Europe to build “a new order of security and stability.”

"The security of our continent,” he continued, “requires a strategic rearmament of our Europe as a power of peace and balance, in particular in the dialogue with Russia.”

On Sunday, Macron was the first French president to win reelection since Jacques Chirac 20 years ago, with a 17-point victory over the far-right populist Marine Le Pen. 

Yet Macron’s reelection by no means ensures that his pursuit of strategic autonomy for Europe will meet with success in the coming years. Indeed, Macron now inherits a politically fractured France at home and a Europe rent by the war in Ukraine abroad. As George Washington University professor and director of its Illiberal Studies Program, Marlene Laruelle, tells me, it may be an election day defeat for Le Pen but for the illiberal franchise in France, “it's a political victory.” Laruelle also noted the record high rate of abstentions: 28 percent generally, with  a record 42 percent rate among young voters, as a worrying sign. 

Abroad, the biggest challenge Macron faces is the Russo-Ukrainian war which — no matter what happens — will inevitably affect the French president’s plans for a more independent, self-sufficient European defense. 

What we can expect, according to professor of International Politics at the American University of Paris, Hall Gardner, is for Macron to “continue to pursue a negotiated settlement.” 

In his view, Gardner, author of the forthcoming book, Toward an Alternative Transatlantic Global Strategy, tells Responsible Statecraft :

“There must be someone to engage in discussions between belligerents even in times of war and despite horrific war crimes. Macron argues that Russia will ‘refuse’ a peace settlement until it achieves some form of ‘victory’ possibly — but not necessarily — by the May 9 Russian celebration of the Soviet defeat of Nazi Germany. Nevertheless, Macron has continued to argue that there will be no peace in Europe unless a new system of European security that incorporates Russia can be constructed once the Russia-Ukraine conflict is settled.” 

But on that front, Macron faces a deeply divided Europe. Laruelle notes:

“The way the U.S., UK and Canada are taking the lead in helping Ukraine is somewhat squeezing Macron's strategy of saying ‘we should have a European vision of autonomy.' I think it can go in both directions: There is an awareness in Europe that, okay, we need to be able to work on this question together. At the same time, because of the war, NATO got reinforced.”

And right now, it seems as though the biggest question with regard to whether Macron will find success in his quest for strategic autonomy is Germany.

Gardner believes that Macron’s plans “will be made easier by the German decision to substantially augment defense spending by 100 billion Euros, plus European efforts to better coordinate defense spending.” 

On the other hand, as Laruelle observes, “Germany is really shifting its prior stance toward Russia and is now joining the Central European narrative on Russia. It's now a more NATO-oriented narrative than it is one in favor of European autonomy.” On Tuesday, the German Defense Ministry announced it will deliver Gepard anti-aircraft tanks to Ukraine for the first time. 

The concern for Macron, says Laruelle, is if Germany “totally embraces the Polish, Baltic, Ukrainian point of view,” which would end up isolating Macron’s project of taking some distance from NATO by pushing for a more autonomous European policy.

Whether Germany’s new-found commitment to defense spending proves to be an ephemeral reaction to the trauma of the Russian invasion remains to be seen.

But what is certain is that the only way out of the conflict is through a peaceful settlement backed by the European powers. To that end, “it is crucial that the U.S. soon begin to take steps to work with, and not against, France and Germany, to seek peace with Moscow in order to wind down this war as soon as possible,” Gardner points out, adding, “if not also accompanied by a diplomatic offensive that will agree to some concessions and compromises with Russia over Crimea and Donbas, the Biden administration’s efforts to ‘weaken’ Russia are playing with fire.”


French President Emmanuel Macron and French first lady Brigitte Macron celebrate with supporters after his victory in France's presidential election in Paris, France on Sunday, April 24, 2022. (Alexandros Michailidis/Shutterstock)|President Emmanuel Macron celebrates his second round win
Analysis | Europe
Kim Jong Un
Top photo credit: North Korean leader Kim Jong Un visits the construction site of the Ragwon County Offshore Farm, North Korea July 13, 2025. KCNA via REUTERS

Kim Jong Un is nuking up and playing hard to get

Asia-Pacific

President Donald Trump’s second term has so far been a series of “shock and awe” campaigns both at home and abroad. But so far has left North Korea untouched even as it arms for the future.

The president dramatically broke with precedent during his first term, holding two summits as well as a brief meeting at the Demilitarized Zone with the North’s Supreme Leader Kim Jong-un. Unfortunately, engagement crashed and burned in Hanoi. The DPRK then pulled back, essentially severing contact with both the U.S. and South Korea.

keep readingShow less
Why new CENTCOM chief Brad Cooper is as wrong as the old one
Top photo credit: U.S. Navy Vice Admiral Brad Cooper speaks to guests at the IISS Manama Dialogue in Manama, Bahrain, November 17, 2023. REUTERS/Hamad I Mohammed

Why new CENTCOM chief Brad Cooper is as wrong as the old one

Middle East

If accounts of President Donald Trump’s decision to strike Iranian nuclear facilities this past month are to be believed, the president’s initial impulse to stay out of the Israel-Iran conflict failed to survive the prodding of hawkish advisers, chiefly U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM) chief Michael Kurilla.

With Kurilla, an Iran hawk and staunch ally of both the Israeli government and erstwhile national security adviser Mike Waltz, set to leave office this summer, advocates of a more restrained foreign policy may understandably feel like they are out of the woods.

keep readingShow less
Putin Trump
Top photo credit: Vladimir Putin (Office of the President of the Russian Federation) and Donald Trump (US Southern Command photo)

How Trump's 50-day deadline threat against Putin will backfire

Europe

In the first six months of his second term, President Donald Trump has demonstrated his love for three things: deals, tariffs, and ultimatums.

He got to combine these passions during his Oval Office meeting with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte on Monday. Only moments after the two leaders announced a new plan to get military aid to Ukraine, Trump issued an ominous 50-day deadline for Russian President Vladimir Putin to agree to a ceasefire. “We're going to be doing secondary tariffs if we don't have a deal within 50 days,” Trump told the assembled reporters.

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.