Follow us on social

U.s._marines_with_the_11th_marine_expeditionary_unit_fire_an_m777_howitzer_during_a_fire_mission_in_northern_syria_as_part_of_operation_inherent_resolve_mar._24_2017-scaled

Reviving the Iran nuclear deal is the key to regional stability

Without it, the United States and its military will be bogged down in the Middle East indefinitely.

Analysis | Middle East

Iran’s new administration has concluded its lengthy internal review on how, and with what new strategies, to return to the Vienna nuclear talks, to find out practical solutions to the current impasse in reviving the 2015 agreement.

The negotiations have been halted since Iran’s presidential election in June 2021 but are set to resume on Monday. Although Iran and the United States are very skeptical about the other side’s intention and seriousness toward restoring the nuclear deal, there is no better and viable alternative than the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) to resolve Iran’s nuclear program.

Under the agreement, Iran temporarily dismantled much of its nuclear program and permanently gave international inspectors extensive access to its facilities in exchange for relief from international economic sanctions. President Trump withdrew from the JCPOA in, 2018 purportedly to renegotiate a “better deal.” One year after Washington reimposed unilateral sanctions, Iran started to gradually reduce its obligations under the deal, and has advanced its nuclear capabilities far beyond 2015 capacity. The Biden administration must prioritize its efforts to restore the deal to advance international and regional security.

The Iranian nuclear file has been the only case among the various disputes between Iran and the West that still has the capability to reach a consensus between all permanent members of the United Nations Security Council. Iran would also like the issue to be resolved peacefully, while maintaining its international rights for a civilian nuclear program based on the Non-Proliferation Treaty, so that Iran pays the least cost to secure its prestige and rights.

In this respect, the JCPOA has already proven to satisfy all parties in the long-term. For example, according to the deal, if restored, all parties in about two years will consider “Transition Day,” which will trigger the United Nations to lift missile restrictions, the European Union to terminate all remaining nuclear sanctions, the United States to seek legislative termination or modification of certain sanctions, and, most importantly, Iran to seek permanent ratification of the Additional Protocol in the Iranian parliament.

Under the Additional Protocol and other strong monitoring mechanisms designated under the JCPOA, the International Atomic Energy Agency is granted expanded rights of access to information and locations in Iran, 24/7. This enables the agency to obtain a much fuller picture of Iran’s nuclear program, plan, and nuclear material holding and trade. The Additional Protocol increases the IAEA’s ability to carry out inspections at undeclared nuclear sites and activities in Iran on short notice to provide much greater assurance on the exclusively peaceful nature of Iran’s nuclear program. The ratification of the Additional Protocol by Iran in 2023, instead of the voluntary agreement to comply, will boost the international community’s confidence in Iran’s nuclear ambitions.

The Obama administration viewed the nuclear deal with Iran as a first step in opening the door to other contentious issues, such as Iran's missile and military capabilities and the influence of Iran and its allies in the West Asia region and Persian Gulf. The U.S. goal, which has remained the same under the Obama, Trump, and Biden administrations, has been to have comprehensive regional security talks with Iran.

However, each administration adopted a different tactics. For example, the Trump administration took a failed unilateral approach, in contrast to the Obama administration's multilateralism. Iran rejected the Trump administration's call for comprehensive talks with Iran, which covered all issues at stake, including nuclear negotiations and regional security talks, and it also lacked international support. The first step to reach comprehensive negotiations is therefore to resolve the nuclear issue, which will then open the pathway to build up mutual understandings and interests.

The United States, regardless of the administration and its party affiliation, wants to divert its security resources to East Asia. China is the only rising world power that is now a serious competitor to the United States in economic, financial, technology, military, and security aspects and will become a “peer competitor” in the next decades. At a time when the United States is spending on its endless wars in the Middle East and its military expenditure around the world, China's exploding economic growth has led most analysts to see China as the world's premier economic power over the next decade.

If the negotiation over the restoration of the JCPOA fails, it can be assumed that Iran's nuclear activities will expand, Iran will heavily reduce its cooperation with the IAEA, and Iran could show more aggressive behaviors in other areas, such as missiles and regional hegemony. In this scenario, it’s unclear whether the United States has the potential to tighten economic sanctions against Iran, already in its maximum capacity. The escalation of sanctions against Iran is currently not an easy and viable option because the U.S. capacity to impose more economic embargoes on Iran has long ago reached its maximum. Robert O'Brien, Trump's national security adviser said as much last October: “One of the problems that we have with both Iran and Russia is that we have so many sanctions out on those countries right now that there's very little left for us to do,” he said.

One of the reasons the JCPOA didn't succeed was because the Obama administration had only one year to strengthen its foundation. President Obama had to deal with a tangled web of sanctions regulations against Iran, which had been accumulated for decades through congressional bills and presidential executive orders.

If the Biden administration seeks to build on the nuclear deal for further talks, meaning regional security, the administration must immediately re-enter the JCPOA and let Iran receive its legitimate benefit from it. Biden would have three more years, before the 2024 U.S. presidential election, to find mutual trust between Iran and the United States. Iranian leaders might more likely be ready to accept a new comprehensive agreement with the West.


SYRIA - U.S. Marines with the 11th Marine Expeditionary Unit fire an M777 Howitzer during a fire mission in northern Syria as part of Operation Inherent Resolve, Mar. 24, 2017. The unit provided 24/7 support in all weather conditions to allow for troop movements, to include terrain denial and the subduing of enemy forces. More than 60 regional and international nations have joined together to enable partnered forces to defeat ISIS and restore stability and security. CJTF-OIR is the global Coalition to defeat ISIS in Iraq and Syria.
Analysis | Middle East
Carlos Trujillo
Top image credit: Continental Strategy LLC founder and president Carlos Trujillo being sworn-in as U.S. Ambassador to the Organization of American States on April 5, 2018. IMAGO/piemags via Reuters Connect

Ex-Trump officials cashing in on Latin American tariff fears

Latin America

Top officials from the first Trump administration are cashing in on Latin American countries' hopes and fears about the president’s trade and tariffs policies, recent filings with the Department of Justice's Foreign Agents Registration Unit reveal.

In August, Continental Strategy, LLC — a government relations firm founded by Carlos Trujillo, Trump's former ambassador to the Organization of American States (OAS), and managed by Alberto Martinez, Secretary of State Marco Rubio's former chief of staff in the Senate — took on two new government clients in the region, Peru and the Dominican Republic's Industry and Trade ministry, for $390,000 and $330,000, respectively.

keep readingShow less
Starmer Macron
Top image credit: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron stand in front of screens during a joint military visit to the MARCOM centre, maritime command centre in Northwood, on July 10, 2025 in London, England. Leon Neal/Pool via REUTERS

France plans risky military deployment while govt is in tatters

Europe

The choice of Paris as the venue for a summit of the European “coalition of the willing” to discuss a “reassurance force” for Ukraine this week has turned out to be deeply unfortunate; for five days after the summit, France may well not have a government. Then again, it’s not clear that any other European capital would have made for a better choice.

France has been plunged into a renewed political crisis by the decision of the prime minister, Francois Bayrou, to hold a parliamentary vote of confidence on September 8 over his plans for steep cuts in public spending in order to reduce France’s public debt while greatly increasing its military spending. French trades unions have promised a general strike on September 18 to block these moves.

keep readingShow less
Daniel Noboa, Xi Jinping
Top photo credit: Beijing, China.- In the photos, Chinese President Xi Jinping (right) and his Ecuadorian counterpart, Daniel Noboa (left), during a meeting in the Great Hall of the People, the venue for the main protocol events of the Chinese government on June 26, 2025 (Isaac Castillo/Pool / Latin America News Agency via Reuters Connect)

Why Ecuador went straight to China for relief

Latin America

Marco Rubio is visiting Mexico and Ecuador this week, his third visit as Secretary of State to Latin America.

While his sojourn in Mexico is likely to grab the most headlines given all the attention the Trump administration has devoted to immigration and Mexican drug cartels, the one to Ecuador is primarily designed to “counter malign extra continental actors,” according to a State Department press release.The reference appears to be China, an increasingly important trading and investment partner for Ecuador.

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.