Follow us on social

Would-be monarch of Iran to brief umbrella org for US Jewish groups

Would-be monarch of Iran to brief umbrella org for US Jewish groups

The Conference of Presidents noted Reza Pahlavi’s ‘calls for regime change’ on the event invite.

Reporting | Middle East

The Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, an umbrella group representing various Jewish American and pro-Israel organizations, is planning to host Reza Pahlavi, the heir apparent to the last Shah of Iran, for an off-the-record “special leadership briefing” on Thursday, bringing questions and condemnations from other pro-Israel and Iranian American groups.

An invitation sent to member organizations and obtained by Responsible Statecraft describes Pahlavi as “a leader and advocate of the principles of freedom, democracy, and human rights for his compatriots” and “call[ing] for regime change through non-violent civil disobedience, and for a free and open referendum on a new government of Iran.”

“Appearing to rally around the reinstating of a repressive non-democratic regime is not a great look for Jewish American leaders,” Foundation for Middle East Peace president Lara Friedman told Responsible Statecraft.

Indeed, Pahlavi’s often well-grounded criticisms of the current Iranian government’s human rights record notably omits any acknowledgement that his father’s rule, which the younger Pahlavi portrays in glowing terms, engaged in brutal repression, lack of political freedoms, and torture. 

That whitewashing of the Shah’s rule was amplified during the Trump administration, with the State Department extolling Iran’s “rich history of human rights from the time of Cyrus up until the 1979 revolution.”

The Conference’s role in supporting the Trump administration’s abrogation of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action with Iran, an agreement that put restraints on Iran’s nuclear program in exhange for sanctions relief, was highlighted by a senior official at a pro-Israel organization that is not a member of the Conference.

"The Conference of Presidents stood against both the consensus of the Israeli security establishment and nearly three-quarters of Jewish US voters when it applauded Donald Trump's violation and abandonment of the anti-nuclear agreement with Iran,” said the official. “If it has time to meet with the figurehead of a long-deposed monarchy, it should also make the time to meet with some of the overwhelming number of nonproliferation and defense experts, Iranian human rights activists and representatives of the American Jewish community who support re-entry to the agreement."

Pahlavi-452x1024

Pahlavi’s support of regime change, raised concerns for at least one Conference member.

When asked if Pahlavi’s calls for regime change were problematic, Hadar Susskind, the president of Americans for Peace Now, a Conference member, responded, "although it’s not clear that the Conference is in fact doing so by inviting him, I think it would be very problematic for an organization that puts itself forward as the voice of the Jewish community to be seen as calling for regime change."

Jamal Abdi, president of the National Iranian American Council, went further, calling out the Council of Presidents for the role its members, which include the pro-Israel and anti-Iran nuclear deal powerhouse American Israel Public Affairs Committee, play in fueling tensions between the United States and Iran.

"[Members of the Conference of Presidents] advocate for crippling sanctions that starve Iranians and exacerbated the spread of Covid in Iran, and worked to unravel the diplomatic accord that ordinary Iranians celebrated as the brightest hope for peace and prosperity," Abdi said. “Instead of standing up external opposition figures willing to put a ‘native’ face on regime change efforts, [the Conference of Presidents] should promote diplomacy and the reduction of external tensions to cultivate the circumstances that historically have enabled populations to organize organically and decide their own political destiny in the face of authoritarian regimes.”

Indeed, it is unclear what, if any, relevant experience or expertise Pahlavi has acquired since his family’s exile from Iran when he was 19 years old that would qualify him as the regime change leader the Conference’s invitation describes.

A 2009 analysis by the Brookings Institution observed that Pahlavi lacks an organized following within Iran, later adding, “[Iranian opposition figures], like Pahlavi, have little in common with the intellectuals and students who make up the core of the reform movement.”

Indeed, Pahlavi’s lack of legitimacy within Iran and “no serious monarchist movement in Iran itself,” according to Brookings, poses more questions than answers about why the Conference of Presidents is holding a closed doors briefing with the last heir apparent to the Imperial State of Iran.

The Conference of Presidents did not respond to questions about why Pahlavi was invited to address the group and whether the conference supports regime change in Iran.

Pahlavi, for his part, has been open about his agenda and strategy, telling the Associated Press in 2017, “My focus right now is on liberating Iran, and I will find any means that I can, without compromising the national interests and independence, with anyone who is willing to give us a hand, whether it is the U.S. or the Saudis or the Israelis or whomever it is.” 


Reza Pahlavi, the last heir apparent to the defunct throne of the Imperial State of Iran and the current head of the exiled House of Pahlavi speaks during an interview with Reuters in Washington, U.S., January 3, 2018. REUTERS/Joshua Roberts|
Reporting | Middle East
Cutting commands is just the start for broken military system
Top photo credit: NORFOLK, Va. (Apr. 15, 2008) Navy Capt. Patricia Cole, director of the Tailored Maritime Operations Center (T-MOC) at the Naval Network Warfare Command, inspects fellow officers during a command-wide bi-annual uniform inspection. U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Corey Lewis File# 080415-N-2147L-001

Cutting commands is just the start for broken military system

Military Industrial Complex

On April 30, new Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness Stuart Scheller, a former Marine Corps Lieutenant Colonel, announced his intent to push for military reform, echoing the frustrations that led to his 2021 court-martial for publicly criticizing the Afghanistan withdrawal.

His call for accountability resonates with my decades-long work as an advocate for transforming the broken U.S. military personnel and leadership systems and addressing the deep-rooted issues in military culture. These would include bloated bureaucracies, careerism, a lack of ethical leadership, and fossilized military doctrine — all which Scheller’s remarks brought into sharp focus.

keep readingShow less
Emmanuel Macron,  Keir Starmer, Friedrich Merz
Top image credit: TIRANA, ALBANIA - MAY 16: France's President Emmanuel Macron, Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Germany's Chancellor Friedrich Merz speak during a Ukraine security meeting at the 6th European Political Community summit on May 16, 2025 at Skanderbeg Square in Tirana, Albania. Leon Neal/Pool via REUTERS

In twist, Europe appears to be deliberately undermining Iran talks

Europe

In a dangerous echo of past miscalculations, the E3 — France, Germany, and the United Kingdom — are once again escalating tensions with Iran, this time by threatening to trigger the reinstatement of U.N. Security Council sanctions (the so-called “snapback”) if U.S.-Iran nuclear talks collapse.

The E3 sees such a step as deploying leverage to force concessions from Iran on its nuclear program. However, it risks derailing diplomacy entirely and plunging the Middle East into deeper crisis.

Leading this charge is France, reprising its role as the E3’s most hawkish voice, reminiscent of its hard line in the JCPOA negotiations in 2015. At a closed-door U.N. Security Council meeting on proliferation at the end of April, French Foreign Minister Jean Noël Barrot exemplified this combative turn, saying that if the U.S. – Iran talks do not bear fruit, France and its European partners “will not hesitate for a second to reimpose all the sanctions that were lifted 10 years ago.”

keep readingShow less
Zelensky
Top photo credit: Volodymyr Zelensky (Shutterstock/Dmytro Larin)

The 2026 bill for the Ukraine war is already in the mail

Europe

Ukraine is already asking for more money to continue fighting into 2026, a sure sign that President Volodmyr Zelensky has no plans to end the war.

With the battlefield continuing to favor Russia, European leaders have their collective heads in the sand on who will pay. How long before President Trump walks away?

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.