Follow us on social

Pope Francis

On Christmas, Pope doubles down, slamming Israel 'cruelty'

This coincides with more evidence that IDF forces are deliberately killing civilians, including children

QiOSK

Roman Catholic Pope Francis drew the ire of the Israeli government on the eve of Christmas week by calling the bombing and killing of children "cruelty."

On Saturday Francis responded to an Israeli airstrike that killed 25 Palestinians in Jabalia, including 12 members of one family, seven of them children. The airstrikes, particularly on Gaza's remaining hospitals and tent encampments housing displaced people, have been a daily occurrence.

“Yesterday children were bombed. This is cruelty, this is not war,” the pope told members of the government of the Holy See.

After his Saturday comments, Israel's foreign ministry shot back calling the Pope's remarks “particularly disappointing as they are disconnected from the true and factual context of Israel’s fight against jihadist terrorism — a multi-front war that was forced upon it starting on October 7.”

So the pope doubled down, remarking Sunday:

“And with pain, I think of Gaza, of so much cruelty, of the children being machine-gunned, of the bombings of schools and hospitals. What cruelty,” the pope said after his weekly Angelus prayer. He also called for a "ceasefire on all fronts, in Ukraine, in the Holy Land, throughout the Middle East and throughout the world."

Interestingly, there are still news organizations that will coyly pretend they do not know what Francis is talking about. From The Times of Israel report, which was bylined by staff and wire services: "It was unclear which specific alleged incidents he was referring to. Israel has long said it only targets terrorists, and that Hamas hides among civilian populations to protect itself."

Aside from a monthlong string of recorded incidents in which hospitals and shelters have been bombed by Israel in Gaza, two devastating reports immediately come to mind as a retort. One, the dozens of doctors and nurses who have returned from Gaza and testify to what they saw. Just one quote:

“One day, while in the E.R., I saw a 3-year-old and 5-year-old, each with a single bullet hole to their head. When asked what happened, their father and brother said they had been told that Israel was backing out of Khan Younis. So they returned to see if anything was left of their house. There was, they said, a sniper waiting who shot both children.”

Another:

“Nearly all new children admitted during my time died. Almost all of these deaths would not have happened if we had proper nutrition, infection control abilities (as simple as soap and hand sanitizer) and adequate supplies.”

The other report came out in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz this week. It quoted soldiers from the Israeli Defense Forces who admitted and described killing innocent civilians at the Netzarim corridor separating north from south Gaza. A quote from a "recently discharged Division 252 officer":

"We're killing civilians there who are then counted as terrorists...The IDF spokesperson's announcements about casualty numbers have turned this into a competition between units. If Division 99 kills 150 [people], the next unit aims for 200."

And another from a "veteran fighter from Division 252":

"One time, guards spotted someone approaching from the south. We responded as if it was a large militant raid. We took positions and just opened fire. I'm talking about dozens of bullets, maybe more. For about a minute or two, we just kept shooting at the body. People around me were shooting and laughing."

But the incident didn't end there. "We approached the blood-covered body, photographed it, and took the phone. He was just a boy, maybe 16." An intelligence officer collected the items, and hours later, the fighters learned the boy wasn't a Hamas operative – but just a civilian.

These are just two reports of many, anecdotal and institutional, about the "cruelty" of the Israel's war on Gaza, which has now claimed more than 45,000 lives and injured more than 107,000 over the last 14 months. Pope Francis has a pulpit and Christmas may be his best time to use it, given that the holiday's origins are in the West Bank, in the town of Bethlehem. But until governments outside the Vatican start taking these calls for ending war more seriously, the meek will hardly inherit the earth ; they will continue to suffer.

Thanks to our readers and supporters, Responsible Statecraft has had a tremendous year. A complete website overhaul made possible in part by generous contributions to RS, along with amazing writing by staff and outside contributors, has helped to increase our monthly page views by 133%! In continuing to provide independent and sharp analysis on the major conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East, as well as the tumult of Washington politics, RS has become a go-to for readers looking for alternatives and change in the foreign policy conversation. 

 

We hope you will consider a tax-exempt donation to RS for your end-of-the-year giving, as we plan for new ways to expand our coverage and reach in 2025. Please enjoy your holidays, and here is to a dynamic year ahead!

Top photo credit: Pope Francis holds an audience to deliver a Christmas message to Vatican workers in Paul VI Hall at the Vatican, December 21, 2024. REUTERS/Ciro De Luca
QiOSK
ukraine war
Diplomacy Watch: Trump's 'gotta make a deal' on Ukraine

Diplomacy Watch: Trump's 'gotta make a deal' on Ukraine

QiOSK

President-elect Donald Trump said early this week that the Ukraine war “has to stop” and that people are “dying at levels nobody has ever seen.”

“Gotta make a deal,” he said about Ukraine. He didn’t say whether a prospective deal could include Ukraine ceding territory to Russia, or deal with Ukraine’s ongoing requests for NATO membership.

keep readingShow less
Ravi Agrawal  Samantha Power
Top photo credit: Ravi Agrawal of Foreign Policy interviews outgoing USAID Administrator Samantha Power, 12/19/24 (ForeignPolicy.com screenshot)

'Humanitarian superstar' Samantha Power admits Gaza is a loss

QiOSK

In an exit interview hosted by Foreign Policy magazine Thursday, editor-in-chief Ravi Agrawal did not waste time asking USAID Administrator Samantha Power what was really on everyone's minds. He turned first to her 2002 book, "A Problem From Hell: America and the Age of Genocide":

"In a Problem from Hell, the book I just mentioned, which made a strong moral case for using American power to prevent human rights crimes around the world, you wrote, and I quote, 'when innocent life is being taken on such a scale, and the United States has the power to stop the killing at a reasonable risk, it has the duty to act.' You wrote that in 2002 I believe, and you're in a position of power now. So I have to ask, why haven't you done more to stop the ongoing atrocities in Gaza, much of which have been committed with weapons funded by U.S. taxpayers?"

keep readingShow less
Syria
Top image credit: Damascus University students stand on the toppled statue of the late Syria's President Hafez al-Assad, father of Bashar al-Assad, after Syria's Bashar al-Assad was ousted, in Damascus, Syria, December 15, 2024. REUTERS/Ammar Awad

The US wants credit for Assad's ouster

Middle East

Officials in the Biden administration are taking credit for creating conditions in Syria that enabled opposition forces to overthrow the Syrian government.

Now that opposition forces have ousted Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, administration officials are insisting that longstanding U.S. policies, including actions taken by the Biden administration against Assad’s supporters, made the overthrow of the Syrian government possible. Administration officials deny that they aided Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), the U.S.-designated terrorist organization that led the drive to overthrow Assad, but they insist that they facilitated the opposition’s victory, citing years of U.S. efforts to empower the opposition and weaken the Syrian government.

keep readingShow less

Trump transition

Latest

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.