Follow us on social

European parliament takes a hard line on Iran

European parliament takes a hard line on Iran

Despite the country's new president expressing interest in reengaging with the West, the EP's Iran delegation doesn't appear interested

Analysis | Europe

As Iran’s president-elect Massoud Pezeshkian is sending messages about his readiness to reengage with the West, the newly elected European Parliament seems to be moving ever further in a hawkish direction. That can be concluded from the appointment of the German Green Party lawmaker Hannah Neumann to chair the EP’s delegation to Iran in the assembly. Save for a major, and unlikely, upset, she’ll be formally endorsed in that position when the body reconvenes after its summer recess.

According to European Parliament rules, the task of inter-parliamentary delegations is to maintain and deepen relations with the parliaments of non-EU countries. Delegations are not the most influential bodies in the EU but they can offer a valuable channel of communication with third countries, particularly in cases when official relations are strained, as is the case with Iran. Or, alternatively, they can become a forum for ventilating grievances against those countries, thus contributing to shaping negative narratives and creating a political climate detrimental to productive diplomacy.

Neumann is not a newcomer to the Iran file. It remains to be seen how she’ll approach her new position, but if her past activities are any indication, we should expect a rather confrontational stance.

A member of the German Greens, the same party to which German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock belongs, Neumann was outspoken in her criticisms of the Iranian government. She consistently campaigned for the inclusion of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards (IRGC) in the EU terrorist list — a step opposed by the EU’s former high representative on foreign policy Josep Borrell on legal grounds. Politically, blacklisting an official security force of Iran will likely provoke more problems in the EU’s relations with Tehran. When Borrell’s successor, former Estonian prime minister Kaja Kallas, acceded to the post, Neumann urged her to take that step, even though unanimity among the all member states will be required to make it effective.

In one particularly strident intervention on the heels of the “Woman. Life. Freedom” movement in Iran, Neumann last year disparaged Borrell’s diplomatic engagement with Tehran by calling on him to “stop stabilizing the brutal regime while the people of Iran are prepared to die for its downfall.” In a debate in April, following exchanges of strikes between Israel and Iran, she spoke of the need to build a regional security architecture to stop the cycle of escalation yet seemed to blame mostly Iran and its allies for that escalation — while she condemned, rightly, Iran’s strike on Israel, she did not mention the Israeli deadly strike on the Tehran’s diplomatic compound in Damascus, which provoked Iran’s retaliation in the first place.

While Neumann has chastised the Islamic Republic’s lack of democratic representation, her pro-democracy zeal was markedly less pronounced in her role as the chair of the European Parliament’s delegation for relations with the Arabian Peninsula (2019-2024) which covers ties with all the Persian Gulf countries. In 2021, the European Parliament adopted a resolution condemning human rights abuses in the United Arab Emirates that included a clause urging the EU to boycott the Expo 2020 in Dubai as a sign of disapproval of Abu Dhabi’s repression. Nevertheless, Neumann visited the Expo in clear contravention of the parliament’s position, which was overwhelmingly supported by her own political faction.

Neumann praised the late president of the UAE Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed al-Nahyan for ushering the UAE into “an unprecedented era of growth and modernization,” without any reference to the country’s human rights record, even as she lashed out at Borrell, EU Council President Charles Michel, and humanitarian aid commissioner Janez Lenarcic for following the standard diplomatic protocol of expressing condolences for the death in a helicopter crash of the Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi two months ago.

Neumann compared working with the Gulf’s Arab countries to walking a diplomatic tightrope, suggesting the need to balance human rights concerns with other interests, such as climate change, women’s rights, economic cooperation, etc. That is sensible. However, it doesn’t appear as if she is prepared to embrace the same spirit in dealing with Iran. In fact, she greeted her appointment as the chair of the Iran delegation with a narrow focus on a “fight for a democratic and free Iran.”

If anything, such rhetoric risks turning the delegation into an echo chamber of constantly regurgitated talking points about how bad the Iranian regime is and the need to remove it. It may work well on social media and offer a sense of moral satisfaction, but it is unlikely to advance a more nuanced understanding of Iranian realities. The delegation, in concrete terms, would likely not be welcome in Tehran to meet with its counterparts in the Iranian Majles, which is one of the primary tasks of the body. In the past, such visits occurred with a certain regularity, and that did not preclude participating MEPs from expressing strong opinions on human rights and other aspects of the Iranian policies. Neumann, however, appeared to rule out any legitimacy for the current parliament which was elected this spring.

As an organizer and participant of many such undertakings in the past, I can definitely affirm that mutual visits help to build trust, better understand the other side’s perspectives — without necessarily agreeing with those perspectives — and ultimately widen the space for diplomacy. Contrary to Neumann and many other MEPs’ criticisms of a diplomatic outreach to Iran, the truth is that in the past 45 years, there was never too much of it but rather too little. Shutting down one available channel, at a time when Tehran is showing more flexibility towards the West, especially Europe, would not be wise, and would work to reduce the EU’s diplomatic relevance.


France, Strasbourg, 2023-12-13. Member of the European Parliament Group of the Greens/European Free Alliance Hannah Neumann in the Meeting of European Parliament Plenary session - Council and Commission statements - European Defense investment program (EDIP). Photograph by Genevieve Engel via REUTERS

Analysis | Europe
President Trump with reporters
Top photo credit: President Donald Trump speaks with members of the media at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland on Sunday, September 7, 2025. (Official White House Photo by Daniel Torok)

Is Israel forcing Trump to be the capitulator in chief?

Middle East

President Donald Trump told reporters outside a Washington restaurant Tuesday evening that he is deeply displeased with Israel’s bombardment of Qatar, a close U.S. partner in the Persian Gulf that, at Washington’s request, has hosted Hamas’s political leadership since 2012.

“I am not thrilled about it. I am not thrilled about the whole situation,” Trump said, denying that Israel had given him advance notice. “I was very unhappy about it, very unhappy about every aspect of it,” he continued. “We’ve got to get the hostages back. But I was very unhappy with the way that went down.”

keep readingShow less
Europe Ukraine
Top image credit: German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, French President Emmanuel Macron, Volodymyr Zelenskyi, President of Ukraine, Keir Starmer, Prime Minister of the UK, and Donald Tusk, Prime Minister of Poland, emerge from St. Mary's Palace for a press conference as part of the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Kiev, May 10 2025, Kay Nietfeld/dpa via Reuters Connect

Is Europe deliberately sabotaging Ukraine War negotiations?

Europe

After last week’s meeting of the “coalition of the willing” in Paris, 26 countries have supposedly agreed to contribute — in some fashion — to a military force that would be deployed on Ukrainian soil after hostilities have concluded.

Three weeks prior, at the Anchorage leaders’ summit press conference, Russian President Vladimir Putin noted that Ukraine’s security should be ensured as part of any negotiated settlement. But Russian officials have continued to reiterate that this cannot take the form of Western combat forces stationed in Ukraine. In the wake of last week’s meeting, Putin has upped the ante by declaring that any such troops would be legitimate targets for the Russian military.

keep readingShow less
After bombing, time to demystify the 'Qatar lobby'
Top photo credit: The Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Qatar, Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Thani, is standing third from the left in the front row, alongside the Minister of Culture of Qatar, Abdulrahman bin Hamad bin Jassim bin Hamad Al Thani, who is at the center, and the Minister of Culture, Sports and Youth of Oman, Sayyid Theyazin bin Haitham Al Said, who is second from the right in Doha, Qatar, on May 9, 2024. (Photo by Noushad Thekkayil/NurPhoto)

After bombing, time to demystify the 'Qatar lobby'

Middle East

On Tuesday, Israel bombed Doha, killing at least five Hamas staffers and a member of Qatari security. Israeli officials initially claimed the US green-lit the operation, despite Qatar hosting the largest U.S. military in the region.

The White House has since contradicted that version of events, saying the White House was given notice “just before” the bombing and claiming the strike was an “unfortunate" attack that "could serve as an opportunity for peace.”

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.