Follow us on social

Diplomacy Watch Donald Trump Putin Zelensky

Diplomacy Watch: ‘Coalition of willing’ takes shape, without the US

Meanwhile, Zelensky agrees to partial ceasefire

Reporting | QiOSK

Without Americans’ help, the European “coalition of the willing” is striving to assist Ukraine — to mixed reviews.

Europeans met on Thursday to hash out how European peacekeepers could be sent to Ukraine to enforce an eventual peace deal between Ukraine and Russia. But only Britain, France, Sweden, Denmark and Australia have said they would actually put boots on the ground.

And while Kaja Kallas, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, urged the EU to mount another five billion euros in aid to Ukraine on Thursday, the proposed funds are significantly less than the 40 billion euro aid package floated earlier.

Meanwhile, other diplomatic affairs are progressing quickly. Namely, Trump, Putin, and Zelensky all agreed to a 30 day partial ceasefire that would limit strikes on energy and civilian infrastructure.

Trump and Zelensky had spoken over the phone on Wednesday, where Zelensky agreed to the partial ceasefire proposal.

“I had a positive, very substantive, and frank conversation with President of the United States Donald Trump @POTUS…We agreed that Ukraine and the United States should continue working together to achieve a real end to the war and lasting peace,” Zelensky said of the call. “We believe that together with America, with President Trump, and under American leadership, lasting peace can be achieved this year.”

“We are very much on track,” Trump said, sharing Zelensky’s positive view of the conversation.

In his own call with Trump Tuesday, Putin had stopped short of halting the use of missile, drone and bomb attacks against Ukraine altogether for 30 days, as initially suggested by Trump.

While a major development, it’s not clear when the partial ceasefire will go into effect. In the meantime, Ukraine attacked an air base deep within Russia Thursday overnight, and Russia was accused of drone-striking two Ukrainian hospitals after ceasefire-related talks. “Everything will continue to fly,” Mr. Zelensky explained, until “there is an appropriate document” negotiating the partial ceasefire’s terms.

Europeans, meanwhile, are skeptical.

“Attacks on civilian infrastructure in the first night after this supposedly pivotal and great phone call have not abated,” German defense minister Boris Pistorius told German broadcaster ZDF. “Putin is playing a game here and I’m sure that the American president won’t be able to sit and watch for much longer.”

“It is clear that Russia does not really want to make any kind of concessions,” Kaja Kallas said, similarly downplaying the deal.

In contrast, other observers felt the call was a positive step toward peace.

“If the diplomatic overtures of the past several months were seen by some as opaque, then today’s phone call between President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin cannot be taken as anything but proof positive that the rubber has hit the road on serious, substantive U.S.-Russia negotiations over a Ukraine peace deal,” Quincy Institute Research Fellow Mark Episkopos wrote for RS. “The energy-infrastructure truce represents substantial progress, negotiated under what is militarily a difficult situation for Ukraine, in slowly shifting from war onto a de-escalatory trajectory.”

In other Ukraine War news this week:

According to AP, Italian PM Giorgia Meloni has ruled out sending Italian troops to Ukraine. "We believe that the dispatch of European troops proposed in a draft by Britain and France is a very complex, risky and ineffective option,'' she explained, referencing previously floated plans for a mainly European peacekeeping force in Ukraine. She said she supported Trump’s ongoing efforts to broker a ceasefire deal between Russia and Ukraine.

Ukraine and Russia successfully conducted a prisoner swap on March 19, according to Al Jazeera, where Moscow returned 175 soldiers and 22 wounded prisoners of war. Ukraine returned 175 Russian soldiers in turn.

Meanwhile, Ukraine is mounting an offensive on the Russian city Belgorod, which borders Ukraine. At least one soldier has been killed in related shelling, according to Reuters, and the governor of the Belgorod oblast admitted the situation is “difficult.”

According to the Guardian, Trump told Zelensky that the U.S. could take ownership of Ukrainian nuclear power plants through a ceasefire agreement. “He said that the United States could be very helpful in running those plants with its electricity and utility expertise,” White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt explained in a press conference Wednesday. “American ownership of those plants would be the best protection for that infrastructure and support for Ukrainian energy infrastructure,” Leavitt said.

Zelensky, however, has said that the talks focused only on the Zaporizhzhia power plant, currently occupied by Russia, and that they were about recovering it, rather than the U.S. owning it. “I told him [Trump]: ‘Yes, if it is possible to modernize, invest money, etc., we are ready to discuss it with you.’ But we spoke exclusively about one station that is under temporary occupation by Russia,” he had said, according to the Hill.

From State Department Press Briefing on March 19:

“We’ve been in this really fast environment where everything’s happening fast. The good news is, so is peace. We’ve never been closer,” State Department Spokesperson Tammy Bruce said, summing up the status of Ukraine war diplomatic talks, including the Trump-Putin call. She said negotiations towards a “maritime ceasefire in the Black Sea,” or even a “full ceasefire and permanent peace,” may occur in the near future.

“Special Envoy [Steve] Witkoff met with Putin last week. Last weekend Secretary [Marco] Rubio spoke with Foreign Minister [Sergey] Lavrov. And, of course, Secretary Rubio and National Security Advisor [Mike] Waltz met with the Ukrainian delegation in Jeddah. Negotiations will continue in Saudi Arabia in the coming days," Bruce explained.

“We’ve been in this really fast environment where everything’s happening fast. The good news is, so is peace. We’ve never been closer,” State Department Spokesperson Tammy Bruce summed up the status of Ukraine war diplomatic talks.

She also referenced talks likely set to begin Sunday or next week in Saudi Arabia.


Top Photo Credit: Diplomacy Watch (Khody Akhavi)
Reporting | QiOSK
Warfare movie A24
Top photo credit: (official trailer for Warfare/A24)
'Warfare': Rare Iraq film that doesn't preach but packs truth

'Warfare': Rare Iraq War film that doesn't preach but packs punch

Media

Unlike Alex Garland’s Civil War, his Warfare, co-directed with war vet Ray Mendoza, is not just another attempt at a realistic portrayal of war, in all its blood and gore. Warfare, based on a true story, is really a parable about the overweening ambition and crushing failure of empire, a microcosm of America’s disastrous adventure in Iraq.

A Navy Seal mission reconnoiters a neighborhood in Ramadi. “I like this house,” says the team commander, reflecting the overconfidence of the empire at its unipolar moment. But it soon becomes clear that the mission has underestimated the enemy, that the whole neighborhood has, in fact, been tracking the Seals’ movements. Surprised and scared, the mission requests to be extricated. But extrication becomes a bloody, hellish experience despite the Seals’ technological edge in weapons, IT, and logistics, and it barely succeeds.

keep readingShow less
vietnam war memorial washington DC
Top photo credit: Washington, DC, May 24, 2024: A visitor reads the names of the fallen soldiers at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial at the National Mall ahead of Memorial Day. (A_Kiphayet/Shutterstock)

Veterans: What we would say to Trump on this Memorial Day

Military Industrial Complex

This Memorial Day comes a month after the 50th anniversary of the Fall of Saigon, which was largely used to recall the collapse of the entire American project in Vietnam. In short, the failure of the war is now viewed as both a rebuke of the American Exceptionalism myth and the rigid Cold War mentality that had Washington in a vice grip for much of the 20th Century.

“The leaders who mismanaged this debacle were never held accountable and remained leading players in the establishment for the rest of their lives,” noted author and professor Stephen Walt in a RS symposium on the war. “The country learned little from this bitter experience, and repeated these same errors in Iraq, Afghanistan, and several other places.”

keep readingShow less
Ukraine war
Top image credit: HC FOTOSTUDIO via shutterstock.com

Should a Russia-Ukraine peace leave territorial control for later?

Europe

Since the beginning of President Donald Trump’s second term, there have been ongoing diplomatic efforts to broker a peace settlement in the three-year-long war between Russia and Ukraine. So far, however, negotiations have failed to bridge the stark divide between the two sides.

Two of the key contentious issues have been post-war security guarantees for Ukraine and the political status of Ukrainian territory claimed or annexed by Russia. Specifically, regarding territorial sovereignty, Ukraine and Russia have rejected the United States' proposal to “freeze” the war along the current line of conflict as a de facto new border. Ukraine has refused to renounce its claims of sovereignty over territories occupied by Russia (including Crimea, which was annexed in 2014). Russia, in turn, has demanded Ukraine’s recognition of Russia’s territorial claim over the entirety of the four Ukrainian regions, which Russia annexed in 2022.

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.