Follow us on social

Shutterstock_1181976658-scaled

Gorsuch appears skeptical of FBI’s state secrets defense in Muslim discrimination case

The case could mark a big turning point in the government’s power grab in the ‘war on terror.’

Reporting | Global Crises

The Supreme Court on Monday heard arguments on whether to proceed with a case that involves Muslim Americans claiming the FBI illegally surveilled them based on their relegious beliefs, while the government alleges that allowing it to move forward would divulge information that would harm U.S. national security. 

A lower court previously dismissed the case on those grounds, but in 2019 a federal appeals court reversed that decision, saying that the judge should have been able to review the information the FBI says will be harmful if released. 

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who was appointed by President Trump, appeared to be sympathetic to the plaintiffs’ case. He said the government’s position is that “we’re entitled to use that evidence in our possession without telling you anything about it as a basis for dismissing the suit more or less as a matter of routine.”

He said the government’s claim that it doesn’t have to choose between keeping secrets and defending itself is “quite a power,” particularly “in a world in which the national security state is growing larger every day.”

A government lawyer told the Court on Monday that the case should be dismissed “because the information concerning the reasons, the subjects, the sources and methods of this foreign intelligence investigation was so central to the case.” 

The plaintiffs’ attorney, meanwhile, said the case could go forward without the secret evidence and can instead rely on public information. 


Photo: davidsmith520 via shutterstock.com
Reporting | Global Crises
Trump should take the victory in Canada and move on
Top photo credit: Pierre Poilievre and Mark Carney (Yan Parisien; bella1105 via shutterstock)

Trump should take the victory in Canada and move on

North America

Just days after replacing Justin Trudeau and becoming Canada’s 24th prime minister, Mark Carney has advised Governor General Mary Simon to dissolve Parliament. Canadians will now head to the polls on April 28 for a long awaited and highly anticipated federal election.

Trudeau had announced his intention to resign as prime minister and Liberal Party leader on January 6, having served more than nine years as Canada’s head of government. Opinion polling had shown an increasingly sizable lead for the rival Conservative Party over the preceding 18 months, with about 25 percentage points separating the two parties by the time Trudeau announced he was stepping down.

keep readingShow less
Alexander Vindman's new book is a folly: of history, and the truth
Top photo credit: Alexander Vindman (Philip Yabut/Shutterstock) and the cover of his new book (publisher, PublicAffairs)

Alexander Vindman's new book is a folly: of history, and the truth

Europe

Alexander Vindman’s recent book, “The Folly of Realism,”throws down the gauntlet, as the name suggests, at the “realists” he thinks were responsible for failing to deter Russia and seize opportunities for defense cooperation with Ukraine.

According to Vindman, the former National Security Council official who testified against President Trump during his impeachment trial in 2019, this “realist” behavior incentivized Moscow’s continued imperialist predations, culminating in the 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

keep readingShow less
arrest free speech
Top photo credit: Spaxiax/Shutterstock

Does Vance’s free speech defense in Munich not apply here?

Global Crises

At the Munich Security Conference in mid-February, U.S. Vice President JD Vance warned Europe not to back away from one of the West’s most basic democratic values: free speech.

“In Washington there is a new sheriff in town," he said, "and under Donald Trump’s leadership, we may disagree with your views, but we will fight to defend your right to offer it in the public square, agree or disagree.”

keep readingShow less

Trump transition

Latest

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.