Follow us on social

2022-05-01t000000z_1453970683_mt1abcpr808119006_rtrmadp_3_abaca-press-scaled

The US will gain nothing by declaring Russia a terror state: experts

Observers say Pelosi’s suggested move may be cathartic but could do more harm than good in the long run.

Reporting | Europe

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi told Secretary of State Antony Blinken that Congress will designate Russia as a state sponsor of terrorism if the executive branch doesn’t, according to Politico.

The move would no doubt be cathartic for Americans who are outraged by Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine, which has killed thousands of civilians and displaced millions. But it will have little effect on the war, according to experts who spoke with Responsible Statecraft. In fact, it may even end up doing more harm than good.

“The Kremlin will simply dismiss the charges as anti-Russian propaganda,” said Rajan Menon, the director of the grand strategy program at Defense Priorities. Menon added that, while further sanctions would lead to more pain for Russians, it is unlikely that they would have a significant impact on President Vladimir Putin’s calculus.

“Plus the pain is a [two-way] street,” he added. “Just consider the boomerang effect on Western economies.”

Blinken can unilaterally place Russia on America’s list of state sponsors of terrorism, which currently includes Iran, North Korea, Cuba, and Syria. He has so far hesitated to do so, arguing that the designation would in many ways be redundant.

But the State Department’s public justification may obscure more practical concerns. As Edward Fishman of the Atlantic Council told Politico, putting Moscow on the list “would be significant because it’s a blanket measure” that “injects a risk into all dealings with Russia.” 

This pervasive risk would make it difficult to do any business with Russian companies, including those that provide vital supplies of gas and food to America’s allies. With the European Union already urging its citizens to ration gas, the designation could deal another blow to the West’s united front on Ukraine, which has already suffered from the political crisis in Italy caused by disagreements over the war.

The Politico piece notes that the congressional designation would not be enough to force Blinken’s hand but could add significant political pressure to make the move.

“If either resolution passes on Capitol Hill — or a full terrorism sponsor designation gets through both chambers — Blinken may feel more pressure to side with lawmakers and make the designation,” wrote reporters Alexander Ward and Betsy Woodruff Swan.

Whether or not the designation comes from the State Department, the move would make it more difficult to conduct diplomacy with Moscow on a range of issues. (Who could forget former President George W. Bush’s famous assertion that “no nation can negotiate with terrorists”?)

And concerns go beyond this particular case: The state sponsor of terror list has long suffered from a crisis of legitimacy, made worse last year when former President Donald Trump added Cuba to the list despite scant evidence of support for actual terrorism. As Barbara Slavin argued in Responsible Statecraft at the time, U.S. terror designations have “become overly politicized and now amount to counterproductive expressions of disapproval for adversarial regimes and groups.”

“When one considers the tens of thousands of innocent civilians killed as a result of U.S. policies, [...] the hypocrisy and counterproductive nature of these designations becomes even more apparent,” Slavin wrote. “The violent actions of other groups on the list, while reprehensible, in many cases are technically acts of war not terrorism.”


Handout photo shows Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy meets with Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, during her visit to the Ukrainian capital of Kyiv, Ukraine, on May 1, 2022. Pelosi is now the highest-ranking U.S. official to visit Ukraine during the war, with the surprise visit adding to the growing momentum behind the West’s support for the country's fight against Russia. Photo by Ukrainian Presidency via ABACAPRESS.COM
Reporting | Europe
Trump's most underrated diplomatic win: Belarus
Top image credit: Brian Jason and Siarhei Liudkevich via shutterstock.com

Trump's most underrated diplomatic win: Belarus

Europe

Rarely are foreign policy scholars and analysts blessed with as crystalline a case study in abject failure as the Western approach to Belarus since 2020. From promoting concrete security interests, advancing human rights to everything in between, there is no metric by which anything done toward Minsk can be said to have worked.

But even more striking has been the sheer sense of aggrieved befuddlement with the Trump administration for acknowledging this reality and seeking instead to repair ties with Belarus.

keep readingShow less
These Israeli-backed gangs could wreck the Gaza ceasefire
Ashraf al-Mansi walks in front of members of his Popular Army militia. The group, previously known as the Counter-Terrorism Service, has worked with the Israeli military and is considered by many in Gaza to be a criminal gang. (Via the Facebook page of Yasser Abu Shabab)

These Israeli-backed gangs could wreck the Gaza ceasefire

Middle East

Frightening images have emerged from Gaza in the week since a fragile ceasefire took hold between Israel and Hamas. In one widely circulated video, seven blindfolded men kneel in line with militants arrayed behind them. Gunshots ring out in unison, and the row of men collapse in a heap as dozens of spectators look on.

The gruesome scenes appear to be part of a Hamas effort to reestablish control over Gaza through a crackdown on gangs and criminal groups that it says have proliferated during the past two years of war and chaos. In the minds of Israel and its backers, the killings reveal Hamas’ true colors — and represent a preview of what the group may do if it’s allowed to maintain some degree of power.

keep readingShow less
Poland farmers protest EU
Top photo credit: Several thousand people rally against a proposed EU migration scheme in Warsaw, Poland on 11 October, 2025. In a rally organized by the opposition Law and Justice (PiS) party thousands gathered to oppose the EU migration pact and an agriculture deal with Mercosur countries. (Photo by Jaap Arriens / Sipa USA)

Poland’s Janus face on Ukraine is untenable

Europe

Of all the countries in Europe, Poland grapples with deep inconsistencies in its approach to both Russia and to Ukraine. As a result, the pro-Europe coalition government of Prime Minister Donald Tusk is coming under increasing pressure as the duplicity becomes more evident.

In its humanitarian response to Ukraine since the war began in 2022, Poland has undoubtedly been one of the most generous among European countries. Its citizens and NGOs threw open their doors to provide food and shelter to Ukrainian women and children fleeing for safety. By 2023, over 1.6 million Ukrainian refugees had applied for asylum or temporary protection in Poland, with around 1 million still present in Poland today.

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.