Follow us on social

Ben Gvir Kristi Noem

Is Trump orbit rolling out red carpet for Israeli extremist Ben Gvir?

A Jewish supremacist known for his role in the violent settler movement, Netanyahu's national security minister reportedly plans to meet with Kristi Noem, and more.

Analysis | Middle East

Few American politicians can claim to back Israel more emphatically than Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-N.Y.).

Since the Oct. 7 attacks, Torres has dedicated himself to defending Israel and striking out against those who criticize its war in Gaza, earning him the moniker of “Israel’s loudest House supporter.” These efforts have garnered high praise from Israeli leadership. “Congressman Torres reflects our extraordinary ties and true friendship,” Israel’s defense minister said last year after meeting with the lawmaker.

So it may seem odd that, when Torres heard Israel’s national security minister was visiting Washington this week, he went on the attack. “There is no universe in which I would ever grant an audience to an extremist like [Itamar] Ben Gvir,” Torres tweeted, adding that he has “nothing but contempt” for the Israeli minister.

As Torres’ comments suggest, Ben Gvir is no ordinary Israeli official. The far-right minister has become a symbol of his country’s most aggressive political currents — a reputation that he earned through decades of activism in support of Jewish Israelis accused of attacks on Palestinian civilians. This, combined with his calls for annexation of Palestinian land and his backing of violent settler groups in the West Bank, led the Biden administration to boycott Ben Gvir and even consider slapping sanctions on him despite his prominent role in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s cabinet.

Luckily for Ben Gvir, there’s a new leader in Washington. President Donald Trump, far from boycotting the Israeli minister, is reportedly ready to roll out the red carpet for him. On April 21, Ben Gvir will fly to the United States for his first ever official visit abroad, according to reports in Israeli media. The trip will include stops in Florida and Washington, DC, where he’s slated to meet with U.S. officials, conservative influencers, and Jewish community leaders.

The most high-profile meeting on his schedule is with Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem.

As of this writing, there is no indication as to what Noem and Ben Gvir might discuss, but there’s reason to believe the pair will hit it off. Noem portrays herself as the ultimate tough-on-crime politician. She recently posed for a controversial photo op at a notorious prison in El Salvador where the administration sent more than 230 migrants accused, without due process, of membership in a Venezuelan gang.

Ben Gvir, who runs Israel’s prison system, has advocated a more straightforward solution for dealing with unwanted detainees. “It is unfortunate that I have had to deal in recent days with whether Palestinian prisoners should receive fruit baskets,” he said last year. “They should be killed with a shot to the head.”

'I don't do it for the money'

Ben Gvir got his start in politics in the early 1990s, cutting his teeth as a teenage activist for Israel’s Kach party. At the time, the group was under threat from all angles. Israeli courts had banned it from participating in elections, and an Egyptian-American attacker had just gunned down its charismatic leader, Israeli-American Rabbi Meir Kahane.

Under Kahane, the Kach party focused largely on ensuring Jewish supremacy in Israel. The group advocated criminal penalties for intermarriage between Jews and non-Jews and called for the denaturalization of all Palestinian citizens of Israel. Among Kahane’s most controversial stances was that any Arab caught throwing stones at Israeli soldiers should be treated as a terrorist, meaning, in Kahane’s view, that the person should be killed and that their entire home village should be expelled from the country.

Back in the U.S., Kahane’s Jewish Defense League pledged to protect Jews using “whatever means necessary” and carried out a series of attacks against alleged antisemites, which eventually led the FBI to designate it as a right-wing terrorist group.

The Kach party limped along until 1994, when a Kahanist named Baruch Goldstein donned his Israeli military uniform, stormed into the Ibrahimi Mosque in Hebron and opened fire on the congregation, killing 29 worshippers and injuring another 125. Kach praised Goldstein as a “hero,” leading Israeli authorities to permanently ban the group.

But this didn’t dull Ben Gvir’s enthusiasm. In a 1995 interview, the young activist brandished a hood ornament that he claimed to have taken from Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s car. “We got to his car, and we’ll get to him, too,” Ben Gvir said. A few weeks later, a far-right Israeli activist shot and killed Rabin, derailing the Oslo peace process. (Ben Gvir has no known connection to that attack.)

Ben Gvir spent the rest of the 1990s and the 2000s advocating for the expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank. After a few too many run-ins with the law, including multiple convictions for incitement and support for terrorism, Ben Gvir took his activism from the streets to the courts. He became a lawyer in 2012 and devoted himself to defending Jewish Israelis accused of killing Palestinians. “I don’t do it for the money,” he told Haaretz in 2016. “I truly believe I need to help these people.”

Decades after his first foray into politics, Ben Gvir remains a committed Kahanist. In 2021, he described Kahane as a “holy man, a righteous man,” who was “murdered for the sanctification of God’s name.” Ben Gvir also holds a special place in his heart for the Hebron shooter — so much so that he kept a photo of Goldstein on his living room wall until 2020.

The 'only solution'

As Ben Gvir made waves with his legal activism, he also began working his way into mainstream Israeli politics. In the early 2010s, he joined a neo-Kahanist party called Jewish Power and became an aide to one its leaders, Knesset member Michael Ben Ari. (Around that same time, the State Department banned Ben Ari from entering the United States, citing his support for Kahanism.)

The Jewish Power party remained on the fringes throughout the 2010s. In 2019, when Israeli authorities banned Ben Ari from running in Knesset elections, Ben Gvir took control of the party. Three years later, he launched it into mainstream relevance with a mix of luck and political savvy.

Israeli law says parties need only win 3.25% of the national vote to earn representation in the Knesset, which gives small parties a chance to break into the legislature. In 2021, Ben Gvir took advantage of this fact and ran on a joint list with other small far-right groups, earning him a seat in the Knesset for the first time.

The lawmaker used his new pulpit to advocate for expanded Israeli settlement on Palestinian land, including the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood of East Jerusalem, where he brandished a gun while arguing with Palestinian residents. But his real victory came in 2022, when Netanyahu, desperate to stay in power and out of jail, formed a coalition government with the Jewish Power party, and named Ben Gvir the minister of national security. The deal gave Ben Gvir extraordinary power despite his relatively small base of supporters.

Ben Gvir has relished this high-profile role, which puts him in charge of Israel’s prisons and police force. In the wake of the Oct. 7 massacres, he’s put more guns in the hands of West Bank settlers, ordered police to allow attacks on aid convoys bound for Gaza, and reduced the amount of food available to Palestinian prisoners.

Ben Gvir was often critical of the Biden administration, which he accused of supporting Hamas when it briefly paused arms transfers to Israel. (It probably didn’t help that President Biden had recently slapped sanctions on one of Ben Gvir’s closest allies in the settler movement.) But he’s seen a lot to like in President Trump’s second term. When Trump suggested removing all Palestinians from Gaza and turning the enclave into the “Riviera of the Middle East,” Ben Gvir praised the idea and said that “encouraging” Gazans to leave is the “only solution” for the war.

“Everyone knows that I was right about encouraging migration,” he said. “Today, the president of the most powerful country in the world says that.”

Editor's Note: this article has been updated to reflect the correct date of Ben Gvir's travels to the U.S.


Top photo credit: Ben Gvir (Shutterstock/Barak Shacked) and Kristi Noem (Shutterstock/Maxim Elramsisy)
Analysis | Middle East
Hezbollah
Top photo credit: Flags of Hezbollah in Southern Lebanon (Shutterstock/crop media)
Flags of Hezbollah in Southern Lebanon (Shutterstock/crop media)

Hezbollah to US: It's not in your interest to support Israeli attacks

Middle East

The Secretary-General of the Lebanese Hezbollah movement, Sheikh Naim Qassem, recently asserted that continued instability in Lebanon does not serve U.S. interests.

Qassem made the remarks following an Israeli airstrike on Beirut’s southern suburbs which Israel claimed had targeted a Hezbollah weapons depot.

keep readingShow less
ukraine military
UKRAINE MARCH 22, 2023: Ukrainian military practice assault tactics at the training ground before counteroffensive operation during Russo-Ukrainian War (Shutterstock/Dymtro Larin)
Ukraine War at 3: The victory we demanded and the attrition we got

Ukraine’s battlefield position is deteriorating fast

Europe

The election of U.S. President Donald Trump changed U.S. policy toward Ukraine from “as long as it takes” to seeking a negotiated peace settlement. These negotiations will be driven by the battlefield reality. The side holding the biggest advantage gets to dictate the terms. This gets more complicated if there is no ceasefire during the negotiations and the battlefield remains dynamic. Belligerents may conduct offensive operations while negotiations are progressing to improve their bargaining position. Historically in many conflicts, peace negotiations lasted years, even as the war raged on, such as during the Korean and Vietnam wars. Thus, the balance of power, measured in resources, losses and quality of strategic leadership are critical to the outcome of negotiations.

For Western powers, this carries serious consequences. They have staked their reputation on this conflict and with it, the fate of the rules-based world order. The Global South and the multipolar world order is waiting in the wings to take over. Failure to achieve victory has the potential to fatally undermine that order and remove the West from global leadership, which it has enjoyed for the last several centuries.

keep readingShow less
Russia Navy United Kingdom Putin Starmer
Top Photo: Russian small missile ships Sovetsk and Grad sail along the Neva river during a rehearsal for the Navy Day parade, in Saint Petersburg, Russia July 21, 2024. REUTERS/Anton Vaganov

How Russia’s naval rearmament has gone unnoticed

Europe

Today, there are only three global naval powers: the United States, China, and Russia. The British Royal Navy is, sadly, reduced to a small regional naval power, able occasionally to deploy further afield. If Donald Trump wants European states to look after their own collective security, Britain might be better off keeping its handful of ships in the Atlantic.

European politicians and journalists talk constantly about the huge challenge in countering an apparently imminent Russian invasion, should the U.S. back away from NATO under President Trump. With Russia’s Black Sea fleet largely confined to the eastern Black Sea during the war, although still able to inflict severe damage on Ukraine, few people talk about the real Russian naval capacity to challenge Western dominance. Or, indeed, how this will increasingly come up against U.S. naval interests in the Pacific and, potentially, in the Arctic.

keep readingShow less

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.