Follow us on social

google cta
Xi Jinping and Trump and Putin

US-China-Russia trilateral: first step toward 'concert of powers'?

Even if Thursday's scheduled meeting ends with no concrete results, it is worth doing

Analysis & Opinion | QiOSK
google cta

The trilateral summit scheduled between President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping should be seen as the first tentative step towards — ideally — a “concert of powers” in which the leading states of the world will manage relations between themselves in such a way as to preserve and promote international peace.

In this way, even if the meeting — which is supposed to take place Thursday on the sidelines of the APEC summit — leads to no concrete results, it will still be worth doing. If the ultimate goal is peace and any possibility of co-operation against transnational threats including climate change, rogue AI, and terrorism, it must begin with the fostering of reasonably stable relations between the world’s three most powerful military states.

For the U.S. commentariat whose noses are out of joint about the prospect of Trump treating with “authoritarians” one cannot acknowledge the tremendous rise in Chinese power on one hand and then say Trump treating Xi as an equal is some sort of shameful and unnecessary concession to Beijing.

The open secret is that the U.S. does in fact badly need China’s help in extricating itself and the world from the war with Iran, which has become an unending quagmire. This war was entirely the doing of President Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and had no international or democratic legitimacy whatsoever — or, for that matter, any real basis in U.S. national interests.

China, as the other biggest world economy and largest consumer of energy from the Persian Gulf, has an entirely legitimate stake and role in trying to bring this war to an end. Russia too, it may be remembered, played a critical role in bringing about Obama’s JCPOA nuclear agreement with Iran — the one that Trump so disastrously cancelled.

China might also be able to play a critical role in helping broker a peace settlement in Ukraine; but China needs to be incentivized to do so. Berating Beijing for trading with Russia will achieve nothing.

U.S. hopes of universal American hegemony, set out in the “Wolfowitz Doctrine” of 1992 and followed by every subsequent U.S. administration, have failed utterly and have only contributed to a whole set of wars. Democratic Peace Theory has also failed. The Chinese and Russian authoritarian states are not going away, and have to be engaged if global catastrophes are to be avoided.


Top photo credit : Xi Jinping (Press Service of the President of the Russian Federation /Roman Kubanskiy/Wikimedia Commons); Donald Trump (Gage Skidmore/Flickr) ; Vladimir Putin (White House photo)
Analysis & Opinion | QiOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.