Follow us on social

google cta
OSCE Georgia

Squabble over leadership risks plunging the OSCE into crisis

With the unstoppable Europeans facing off against the immovable Turks, the obvious solution would be to drop objections to Georgia’s candidacy.

Analysis & Opinion | Europe
google cta

The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) is staring down the barrel of entering 2027 without a chair for the first time in its 51-year history.

The Europeans are wrestling Turkey to drop its veto over Cyprus’ bid, raising the stakes by loudly opposing the only other candidate, Georgia. Unable to win over Ankara, Europe should drop its objections to Tbilisi to avert a crisis.

With three weeks to go until the OSCE Ministerial Council in Lugano, Switzerland, on December 3, the organization remains deadlocked over who should lead it from 2027-28. The chairperson-in-office role rotates every two years and is normally voted on well in advance with agreement by consensus. EU member Cyprus was the first country to put its hat in the ring almost two years ago, in December 2024.

However, Cyprus’ bid has been vetoed by Turkey on the basis of the long-standing dispute over the division of the island in 1974. There is a long history of enmity over the issue between NATO members Turkey and Greece, the latter of which has long backed Cyprus and opposed Turkey’s occupation of half of the island. Indeed, each country has vetoed the other across numerous areas of dialogue and cooperation. Just this past week, the Hellenic American Leadership Council (HALC) began lobbying the Trump Administration to veto Turkey’s candidate to become U.N. secretary general.

With this history in mind, it’s clear, at least to me, that the Turkish are never going to back down over Cyprus’ candidature for the OSCE chair role.

That leaves a second candidate, Georgia, which entered the race in January. However, in late September 2026, 14 European countries came out to block Tbilisi, without raising specific objections. This does not represent a veto. Instead, the EU has said that it will not consider other candidates apart from Cyprus, in an election that requires consensus.

Refusing to consider Georgia has resulted in the current stalemate. Europe is effectively taking the chairmanship to the wire, in a bid to force through Cyprus’ candidate. It’s not going to work.

This fight raises the real prospect of the OSCE entering 2027 without a chair, leaving it unable, for the first time, to agree on leadership, budgets or meaningful action on the core security priorities of its region, including on Ukraine.

The organization comprises 57 member states, including the United States, Russia, and most of Europe and Central Asia. A headless OSCE would cripple the only remaining body in Europe that exists to promote dialogue between countries in times of conflict. This at a time when European states have sidelined bilateral diplomacy with Russia because of the Ukraine war, such that the Europeans have been left out of last week’s Abu Dhabi peace talks.

With the unstoppable Europeans facing off against the immovable Turks, the obvious solution would be to drop objections to Georgia’s candidacy.

There are strong arguments in favor of Georgia. It straddles one of the hottest geopolitical crossroads in the world, with Russia to its north and Iran to its south. Turkey, while generally on good terms with Tbilisi, has a deeply troubled relationship with Armenia.

The fraught geopolitical tightrope that Georgia has had to tread on Russia is precisely why it would make a good chair of the OSCE. Indeed, Georgia assumed the chair of the OSCE’s Forum for Security Cooperation in April of this year — and with none of the attending drama.

The current government of Georgia has delivered an impressive track record of economic growth and reform that suggests it has the institutional credentials and credibility to lead. It remains a country committed to future membership in the EU despite the difficulties in the relationship, as the prime minister set out at the recent EU Enlargement Summit.

This last-minute European barrier to Georgia’s candidacy appears in part linked to the deterioration in Georgian-European relations since the start of the war in Ukraine in 2022. While the Georgian government has consistently and repeatedly backed Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity in official statements, it has found itself in the European crosshairs for not joining economic sanctions against Russia or getting involved with the war effort.

The reasons for this are pragmatic. Georgia suffered a brief yet devastating war against Russia in 2008 and the loss of a significant chunk of its territory in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Having visited Georgia often over the past two years, it is clear to me that the loss of territory to Russia represents a deep scar that runs through Georgian society irrespective of which political party citizens support.

The idea that Georgia is a Russian ally because it refuses to expose itself to the risk of another damaging war is frankly ludicrous. Georgia still does not maintain diplomatic relations with Russia. Its careful positioning on the war has occasionally put it at odds with the government of Ukraine. And yet Ukraine is not opposing Georgia’s OSCE bid. Nor are the United States, Canada, Russia, Georgia’s immediate neighbours or the Central Asian participating states.

Georgia has faced criticism from Europe for clamping down on foreign-funded NGOs. Some Western commentators argue that U.S. and European lawmakers want to deliver a Maidan-style revolution in Georgia.

However, these disagreements are entirely incidental to the issue of Georgia’s candidacy to chair the OSCE. The organization was first founded in 1975 (initially as the CSCE) as part of the Helsinki Final Act to facilitate greater dialogue on security between western Europe, the Soviet Union and the Warsaw Pact. It has always been, purposefully, a big tent that even today can accommodate Russia and Ukraine, Armenia and Azerbaijan, Turkey and Cyprus, Kosovo and Serbia, and so on.

It was perhaps inevitable at some point that a party to a frozen conflict within the group would one day step forward to assume the chairman role, prompting a veto from the other party. This is exactly what has happened with Cyprus’ candidature, which has become an immovable blockage with Europe and Turkey unwilling to give ground.

The EU is never going to win that fight, which leaves the OSCE deadlocked with mere weeks to run.

So, the Europeans are in the invidious position of not being able to force through their own candidate for the chairman role while blocking the only other credible candidate, Georgia, on procedural grounds. This is deeply unhelpful in circumstances where neither Ukraine nor Russia see objections to Georgia assuming the role.

If the OSCE enters a new year without a chair, the OSCE will have become a reflection of Europe’s divisions rather than a mechanism for managing them. It’s time for European nations to drop their objections to Georgia’s candidacy and avoid plunging the OSCE into 2027 in a state of crisis.


Top photo credit: Georgia assumes the Chairpersonship of the Forum for Security Co-operation (FSC) of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) on April 22, 2026. Georgia’s bid for chairpersonship of the entire organization is being contested today. (OSCE/Creative Commons)
Analysis & Opinion | Europe

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.