Follow us on social

2022-05-19t161600z_1963985794_mt1sipa000dksyf9_rtrmadp_3_sipa-usa-scaled

US failure to help Afghans is worse than we thought

A new lawsuit alleges that some NGOs set up to help evacuate those who helped the United States in Afghanistan are just a series of scams.

Reporting | Asia-Pacific

Even now, more than a year after the U.S. military withdrawal from Afghanistan, the United States continues to abdicate its responsibility of getting former Afghan partners out of the country, forcing them to turn to desperate measures. A new lawsuit reveals just how bad it’s gotten. 

The nonprofit Save Our Allies alleges they were defrauded out of $735,128 by three different companies and individuals by failing to evacuate 197 Afghan refugees from Afghanistan (via Pakistan) to Qatar in early 2022. According to the complaint, it was a “classic scam” in which defendants “claimed that ‘the planes are prepared to fetch the refugees, if only Save Our Allies and others wired them more money immediately.” 

Save Our Allies claims that one of the defendants, an advising firm in Florida called Ravenswood Group, told the NGO in a letter that it is “out of cash — and it is cash that is needed to get the lady to sing. Don’t worry, she will sing (soon) but we need more help as fast as possible.” 

The complaint alleges that despite wiring hundreds of thousands of dollars to the defendants, they “never had any capability or intent to assist the refugees’ escape from Afghanistan.” 

Save Our Allies was founded in August 2021 amid the U.S. military withdrawal from Afghanistan. It’s one of several organizations set up by veterans to evacuate Afghan interpreters, engineers, and others who served alongside them. 

Kevin Carroll, a partner at Hughes Hubbard & Reed, the law firm that filed the complaint, told Responsible Statecraft that “crisis situations bring out the best and the worst in people. 99 percent of people rally to try and help their fellow man, but some people will use that as an opportunity to make money.”

For the Afghan refugees stuck within the Taliban’s grasp, the Save Our Allies debacle is potentially life-threatening. Ahmad Feroz Bakhshi, an Afghan interpreter who served alongside the Marines, was supposed to be on the plane to Qatar. His attorney, David Laufman, told Responsible Statecraft that he and his family “were about to be exfiltrated from Pakistan to Qatar to bring them out of harm's way to safety and a new life, only for it to fall apart due to this fraud. Now, the Taliban hunts for them in Pakistan and he remains in extreme jeopardy.” Laufman’s son served alongside Bakhshi and he is representing him pro-bono.

According to the complaint, these 197 refugees include both holders of and applicants for the Special Immigrant Visa, the decades-old immigration pathway set up to ensure the safety of interpreters, engineers, and others who assisted the U.S. military. 

That program has moved slowly. A new report by the State Department’s Office of Inspector General found that in May of 2022, there were 325,000 unopened emails in the SIV application email box. As of August 9, there were upwards of 90,000 Afghans stuck in the backlog of the Special Immigrant Visa program. 

The inefficiency of the Special Immigrant Visa program is forcing Afghans to turn toward alternative methods of reaching safety, such as Save Our Allies and other similar nonprofits. But ultimately, an NGO can’t supplant the work of a government that has a responsibility to reconcile with the consequences of a 20-year war. 

“We are not a government. We cannot do what the U.S. government does,” said Nick Palmisciano, the Vice President of Save Our Allies. “My Whatsapp is inundated daily with dozens and sometimes hundreds of messages from people that have gotten my information from somebody that [Save Our Allies] has helped.” 

Adam Weinstein, a Research Fellow at the Quincy Institute, said that the government’s abdication of responsibility in evacuating Afghan partners created a “Wild West” with all kinds of folks getting into the airlift business. 

“The bottom line is the U.S. government dropped the ball on its commitment to get out former interpreters and some others at great risk of Taliban reprisals. The task then fell on a lot of well meaning groups and a few opportunistic ones too.” 

In a statement to Responsible Statecraft, a State Department spokesperson appeared to reject the idea that the U.S. government was leaving the responsibility to private organizations. “The relocation of Afghans has been a historic whole-of-society effort made possible with partnerships across numerous federal agencies; state and local governments; non-profit organizations, including faith-based and veterans’ groups; the private sector; and local communities,” the statement read. 

The spokesperson pointed to some improvements within the SIV program as evidence, namely transitioning to a long-term strategy without an end date and eliminating a duplicitous form. According to the State Department, removing this petition form “will shave a month of adjudication time and ease administrative burden on the visa applicant.” Out of a 14-step process, this form was only step number six. 

Some are proposing going much further. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.) recently published a detailed list of recommendations for improving the SIV program, which includes raising the visa cap, increasing staffing, and streamlining the application process. 

But perhaps the most intriguing short-term solution was Shaheen’s plea for the Biden administration to start utilizing a statute that “requires that the Secretary of State ‘shall make a reasonable effort to provide protection or to immediately remove such aliens from Afghanistan’ should they be in imminent danger.” According to Shaheen “this provision has been underutilized and Afghans have suffered reprisal killings and violence without support from the U.S. government.” 

Ukraine could serve as a precedent. Biden’s “United for Ukraine” program provides a pathway for Ukrainians at risk of violence to come to the United States. “The administration must extend the same protections to Afghans,” urged Shaheen. 

Critics say Russia’s invasion of Ukraine continues to divert attention and resources away from Afghanistan.

“Save our Allies has been doing work in Ukraine and has been since February, so we believe in that mission,” Palmisciano said. “But I would be lying to you if I didn’t tell you that I was incredibly sad and at times overwhelmed by how willing the entire world is to help Ukraine and how unwilling the world is to even acknowledge Afghanistan.” 

According to Palmisciano, Save Our Allies even had plans in place with an unnamed country that had agreed to take 1,000 Afghans. When Russia invaded Ukraine, Save Our Allies was told the Ukrainians would have priority over Afghans. 

Currently, Afghan SIV applicants also have a more burdensome application process than Ukrainians, having to manually request that their case be transferred to another embassy. 

To the thousands of Afghans in SIV-purgatory, including the 197 Afghans who were allegedly defrauded in the Save Our Allies complaint, government inaction has put their lives in jeopardy. Palmisciano knows this better than most; “Every once in a while, one of them is found (by the Taliban), and the men who find them occasionally enjoy sending images of their mutilated corpses via Whatsapp, after going through their phones to see who they’ve been working with.” 


Afghans who fled to Pakistan from Afghanistan after the Taliban took over their country last year hold a protest in Islamabad, Pakistan, on May 19, 2022, demanding the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) to register them and help their asylum seeking process in Europe. (Photo by Raja Imran/Pacific Press/Sipa USA)No Use Germany.
Reporting | Asia-Pacific
Abdourahmane Tchiani, niger
Top photo credit: General Abdourahmane Tchiani, who was declared as the new head of state of Niger by leaders of a coup, arrives to meet with ministers in Niamey, Niger July 28, 2023. REUTERS/Balima Boureima/

Niger's accusation of Western chicanery hits close to home

Africa

As the year 2024 wound to a close, Niger’s junta leader, Brigade General Abdourahmane Tchiani, made accusations that France is using neighboring Nigeria as a staging ground to destabilize his country.

According to Tchiani, who came to power after overthrowing President Mohamed Bazoum in a military coup in July 2023, France offered money to Nigerian authorities “to establish a base in Borno State, with the sole aim of destabilizing our countries” — an apparent reference to other junta-led West African States, Mali and Burkina Faso, which recently split from ECOWAS.

keep readingShow less
C5+1 leaders
Top photo credit: Chinese State Councilor and Foreign Minister Qin Gang attends the China-Central Asia Foreign Ministers' meeting with Kazakhstan's Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Murat Nurtleu, Kyrgyzstan's Minister of Foreign Affairs Kulubaev Zheenbek Moldokanovich, Tajikistan's Minister of Foreign Affairs Sirojiddin Muhriddin, Turkmenistan's First Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Vepa Hajiyev and Uzbekistan's Minister of Foreign Affairs Bakhtiyor Saidov, in Xian, Shaanxi province, China, April 27, 2023. (Reuters)

Central Asia becomes middle power contender in new Trump era

Asia-Pacific

President Donald Trump has caused quite a stir in the media in recent months with his bold statements on a diplomatic solution to the military conflict in and around Ukraine. One of his moves in this direction at the beginning of December was a phone call with Kazakhstan’s president Kassym-Jomart Tokayev asking the latter for his opinion on the issue.

The fact that Trump would pick up the phone to talk to Tokayev suggests that Kazakhstan could play a role as an actor in the search for a diplomatic solution in Ukraine. Furthermore, it underscores Central Asia’s potential to shape the peace and security architecture in Eurasia and beyond. In view of the aspirations of the new Trump administration, it is likely that U.S. policy towards Central Asia may be in line for an upgrade.

keep readingShow less
Donald Trump inauguration 2025
Top photo credit: Vice President JD Vance, President Donald Trump, House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) his wife, Kelly Johnson at Emancipation Hall during the 60th Presidential Inauguration, Monday, Jan. 20, 2025, at the U.S. Capitol in Washington.Graeme Jennings/Pool via REUTERS

Trump: 'our power will stop all wars'

QiOSK

In his inaugural speech Monday, President Donald Trump pledged to build "the strongest military the world has ever seen." It was just one note in a broader composition about restoring confidence and pride in the country — "the start of a thrilling new era of national success."

The newly sworn-in 47th president — his second time since 2017 — did not dwell on specific foreign policy aspirations, but instead weaved them generally into his overall theme of an "America First" era, conjuring the spirits of Ronald Reagan and Teddy Roosevelt and largely ignoring the last 20 years in which the U.S. was largely embroiled in failed wars, proxy or otherwise.

keep readingShow less

Trump transition

Latest

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.