Follow us on social

google cta
Hillary doubles down: Young people don't know why they criticize Israel

Hillary doubles down: Young people don't know why they criticize Israel

The former Secretary of State told Doha audience that Americans just don't have 'context' for what they see plainly with their own eyes in Gaza.

Analysis | QiOSK
google cta
google cta

Hillary Clinton doubled down on her claims that young people get most of their news from social media and therefore are succumbing to anti-Israel propaganda regarding the killing of civilians, the starvation of the population, and destruction of Gaza Strip.

Speaking with Foreign Policy’s Ravi Argawal at the Doha Forum in Qatar Sunday, Clinton repeated what she said at a news conference event sponsored by the far-right Israel Hayom magazine, which is published by Israeli-American GOP megadonor Miriam Adelson. She told the audience then that she has encountered college students who are falling for “pure propaganda” relating to Israel in Gaza and that is why they are protesting genocide.

Argawal pressed her, knowing how much backlash the former first lady has received from her comments in the last several days, as she appeared to be saying that people across the world were duped, that they could not believe with their own eyes what has happened in Gaza for the last two years. "If Americans are shifting in their views about Israel .. that is based on some information they're not just getting from social media but from very reputable sources in the media, including Palestinian journalists in Gaza, why is that …not accurate?" Argawal asked.

"I'm not saying it is inaccurate," she said. "What I am saying … I've had many many conversations with many smart young people … in talking with them about their views — they were certainly entitled to those views base on the information they had — but they did not always know why they said they said."

"We are not going to implement the 20-point plan or any other peace plan unless people come with some sense of historical perspective and empathy of how we are going to move people toward what I believe is the only realistic outcome, a two-state solution, and we won’t get there if they say 'from the river to the sea' and you ask them what that is and they know and that has personally happened in conversations (I've had)."

"This is a larger issue of history ," she added. "We're not giving young people the context they need to be decision makers."

Ironically, Adelson, as reported by my colleague Eli Clifton in these pages, has funneled tens of millions into the Maccabee Task Force, a campaign that promotes pro-Israel propaganda and cracks down on Israel criticism on college campuses. It was behind a 2024 social media campaign against activist Mahmoud Khalil at Columbia University, where Clinton teaches.


Dear RS readers: It has been an extraordinary year and our editing team has been working overtime to make sure that we are covering the current conflicts with quality, fresh analysis that doesn’t cleave to the mainstream orthodoxy or take official Washington and the commentariat at face value. Our staff reporters, experts, and outside writers offer top-notch, independent work, daily. Please consider making a tax-exempt, year-end contribution to Responsible Statecraftso that we can continue this quality coverage — which you will find nowhere else — into 2026. Happy Holidays!

google cta
Analysis | QiOSK
Does Israel really still need a 'qualitative military edge' ?
An Israeli Air Force F-35I Lightning II “Adir” approaches a U.S. Air Force 908th Expeditionary Refueling Squadron KC-10 Extender to refuel during “Enduring Lightning II” exercise over southern Israel Aug. 2, 2020. While forging a resolute partnership, the allies train to maintain a ready posture to deter against regional aggressors. (U.S. Air Force photo by Master Sgt. Patrick OReilly)

Does Israel really still need a 'qualitative military edge' ?

Middle East

On November 17, 2025, President Donald Trump announced that he would approve the sale to Saudi Arabia of the most advanced US manned strike fighter aircraft, the F-35. The news came one day before the visit to the White House of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who has sought to purchase 48 such aircraft in a multibillion-dollar deal that has the potential to shift the military status quo in the Middle East. Currently, Israel is the only other state in the region to possess the F-35.

During the White House meeting, Trump suggested that Saudi Arabia’s F-35s should be equipped with the same technology as those procured by Israel. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu quickly sought assurances from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who sought to walk back Trump’s comment and reiterated a “commitment that the United States will continue to preserve Israel’s qualitative military edge in everything related to supplying weapons and military systems to countries in the Middle East.”

keep readingShow less
Think a $35B gas deal will thaw Egypt toward Israel? Not so fast.
Top image credit: Miss.Cabul via shutterstock.com

Think a $35B gas deal will thaw Egypt toward Israel? Not so fast.

Middle East

The Trump administration’s hopes of convening a summit between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi either in Cairo or Washington as early as the end of this month or early next are unlikely to materialize.

The centerpiece of the proposed summit is the lucrative expansion of natural gas exports worth an estimated $35 billion. This mega-deal will pump an additional 4 billion cubic meters annually into Egypt through 2040.

keep readingShow less
Trump
Top image credit: President Donald Trump addresses the nation, Wednesday, December 17, 2025, from the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House. (Official White House Photo by Daniel Torok)

Trump national security logic: rare earths and fossil fuels

Washington Politics

The new National Security Strategy of the United States seeks “strategic stability” with Russia. It declares that China is merely a competitor, that the Middle East is not central to American security, that Latin America is “our hemisphere,” and that Europe faces “civilizational erasure.”

India, the world's largest country by population, barely rates a mention — one might say, as Neville Chamberlain did of Czechoslovakia in 1938, it’s “a faraway country... of which we know nothing.” Well, so much the better for India, which can take care of itself.

keep readingShow less
google cta
Want more of our stories on Google?
Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

LATEST

QIOSK

Newsletter

Subscribe now to our weekly round-up and don't miss a beat with your favorite RS contributors and reporters, as well as staff analysis, opinion, and news promoting a positive, non-partisan vision of U.S. foreign policy.